Redevelopment of Hamilton Theater at 3560 Broadway Revealed, Harlem

3560 BroadwayFirst proposed redesign of 3560 Broadway, rendering by Todd Zwigard Architects

A proposal by Todd Zwigard Architects that will go before the New York Landmark Preservation Commission later today has revealed plans to redevelop the currently abandoned Hamilton Theater, at 3560 Broadway between West 146th and West 147th Streets, in Harlem. The interiors would be gutted to make way for commercial space on floors two through four, and retail space on the first floor, combined with major alterations and additions to a connecting structure.

The decorative aspects of the façade will be left unaltered, while the connecting brick building will receive some alterations. Larger windows will be installed along its Northern and Southern sides, as well as an addition to unite the two structures on all four floors.

3560 Broadway

Existing 3560 Broadway, rendering by Todd Zwigard Architects

3560 Broadway

Proposed alterations of 3560 Broadway, rendering by Todd Zwigard Architects

Renderings reveal that the original awning will not be replaced, and the theater’s signage on the site’s 146th street corner will be mimicked with a slimmer and less ornate sign with the name, ‘Hamilton’ written in a Helvetica-like font

3560 Broadway Historic Image

3560 Broadway Historic Image courtesy Todd Zwigard Architects

It is undeniable that the current structure is in a state of disrepair. The iconic brickwork and ornamental design have darkened from built-up dirt.

3560 Broadway

Current 3560 Broadway, images courtesy Todd Zwigard Architects

While permits have not been filed for the project, the design does appear to increase square footage significantly and make the building more functional. The LPC’s say will determine whether construction can proceed on the current submission, or if plans will have to be updated.

No official completion date has been announced.

Subscribe to YIMBY’s daily e-mail

Follow YIMBYgram for real-time photo updates
Like YIMBY on Facebook
Follow YIMBY’s Twitter for the latest in YIMBYnews


7 Comments on "Redevelopment of Hamilton Theater at 3560 Broadway Revealed, Harlem"

  1. Welcome Home (David) | October 31, 2017 at 7:41 am | Reply

    Refresh on redevelopment.

  2. I wish the glass awning could be restored as well — it would be so special along the Broadway corridor

  3. According to the Landmarks Commission’s website, this item was laid over and will be considered at another meeting.

  4. Restore the pediment and the awning!

  5. Agreeing with other commenters that the pediment and awning should be restored. That awning was amazing.

    I do like the suggested new windows on the side of the building.

  6. The neighborhood needs a theater, not more empty stores. Shame this proposal seems to destroy the surviving auditorium.

  7. It should be redeveloped as a theater and nothing else!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.