The Trust for Governors Island has proposed the renovation of Building 309 at 309 Clayton Road on Governors Island, to expand its functionality as a public events and community programming space. The proposal, set for review by the Landmarks Preservation Commission on January 27, was assembled by Smith-Miller + Hawkinson Architects. Although situated within the Governors Island Historic District, Building 309 is classified as a non-contributing structure and has no architectural elements deemed necessary for preservation.
Location of 309 Clayton Road, via LPC proposal.
Historically known as “Our Lady Star of the Sea,” the building once served as a chapel before being deconsecrated following the U.S. Coast Guard’s departure in 1996. Over the past year, it has hosted more than 100 events, including Governors Island Arts and NY Climate Week programs. Planned renovations include interior upgrades such as ADA-accessible restrooms, conversion of windows to doors for improved access, installation of a fire alarm and sprinkler system, and construction of a new deck. A seasonal canopy and lighting are also proposed.
Current conditions at 309 Clayton Road, via LPC proposal.
Proposed changes at 309 Clayton Road, via LPC proposal.
The renovation aims to enhance accessibility and infrastructure to support larger gatherings and events. The project received unanimous support from Community Board 1 in December 2025, with construction scheduled to begin in early 2026.
Building 309 is accessible via ferry to Governors Island, with the closest access points at Soissons Landing and Yankee Pier, linking to the 1, R, 4, and 5 trains via Lower Manhattan terminals.
Subscribe to YIMBY’s daily e-mail
Follow YIMBYgram for real-time photo updates
Like YIMBY on Facebook
Follow YIMBY’s Twitter for the latest in YIMBYnews
“Although situated within the Governors Island Historic District, Building 309 is classified as a non-contributing structure and has no architectural elements deemed necessary for preservation.” Amen.